http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=27600
trauma
Al Dicken - 2012/05/07 18:08:30 UTC
Shoot me if you want, but John Orders and Steve Parson are both flying buds of mine.
If you've never had trauma affect your life, consider yourself lucky, but possibly, um, unenlightened as to how it can affect you.
When you and your buds NEVER do, require, look for hook-in checks and something like this happens you don't get to talk about LUCK issues.
some things need to change, for sure, but to be hurtful and negative isn't going to help.
1. Some changes were mandated thirty-one years ago - but everybody treated them neglect or contempt.
2. Doug Hildreth tried for fourteen years to get this message across with the rational and respectful approach and didn't accomplish shit. Let's hurtful and negative a shot and see if we can't get better results. It's a no brainer we can't do any worse.
think pro-active, not re-active. lets try to make our beautiful sport safer
By Jove, YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT! Why didn't I think of that? Now on to a brighter tomorrow!
Neither you nor any of the other total morons in your circle of buds has a freakin' clue what a freakin' hook-in check is. Each and every one of you is a really bad "accident" moving ever forward towards happening.
Brian McMahon - 2012/05/07 18:16:20 UTC
Nobody is going to slam you for your message here.
Come on over to Kite Strings. I'll slam the crap out of it. He's just another halfwit continuing to clog bandwidth and totally ignore the people who know what the hell they're talking about.
It is an unfortunate event and although there was apparently a mistake or series of mistakes, there is nothing to suggest that the same thing couldn't have happened to some other Tandem instructor anywhere in the world.
Bullshit. You wouldn't be saying that if the guy always had three beers while while setting up his glider and prepping for launch and somebody got a broken arm because the launch run left a lot to be desired as a consequence. And what Jon was doing was a lot worse and a lot less forgivable.
But you're probably right about there being nothing to suggest that the same thing couldn't have happened to any other tandem instructor anywhere in the world. I've never seen any evidence that ANY tandem "instructor" is making the slightest effort to include a hook-in check in his launch procedure.
Jaco Herbst - 2012/05/08 01:07:05 UTC
Al,
How is Jon doing?
How do you think he's doing?
I cannot imagine the trauma he must be going through. Hell would be a nice place.
Please convey my sincere sympathy for this unfortunate sinkhole he's found himself in.
He didn't FIND himself in it - He PUT himself in it. And forget the goddam card thing.
As a tandem pilot, I truly do not know how I would've handle this trauma.
You wouldn't be able to. Your life would be destroyed. (But it would be a lot less destroyed if instead of swallowing the card you had handed it over to the investigators IMMEDIATELY.)
He has my one hundred percent moral support in this very difficult time.
How much does that leave over for Lenami's family?
My advice to him. This sinkhole has a bottom. He has to stand up, keep his head up, face the music and start climbing out. Whatever the outcome of this investigation might be...
I don't think the outcome of this investigation is gonna hold a whole lot of surprises.
He has supporters out there.
I sure wish the fuckin' hook-in check had ten percent as many.
Hats off to you for also being there for him.
Thumbs down for doing absolutely nothing to diminish the probability of the next one.
Later
Yeah, that's one thing we can count on. There WILL BE a later.
If at first you don't succeed, lower your standards.
I know your little tag line is meant as a joke but that's EXACTLY what hang gliding culture has always done and that's EXACTLY why Lenami's life got ended and Jon's life got destroyed two weekends ago.
Scott C. Wise - 2012/05/08 04:46:44 UTC
...there is nothing to suggest that the same thing couldn't have happened to some other Tandem instructor anywhere in the world.
I know this was sincerely said and meant in the very best light.
Yeah, the road to hell is paved with the very best of intentions.
But, if this unimaginable situation...
UNIMAGINABLE? We HAD a CARBON COPY of this one on 2003/03/29 - via the courtesy of Steve Parson, another (former) Vancouver tandem instructor.
...had happened to me, it would not make me feel better to think that my mistake(s) could also happen to how many others doing tandems.
It wouldn't HAPPEN to you. It would happen because you would've decided to ignore the message I was trying to get through to you in late August of 2009.
I would sincerely hope that the odds of this happening to any other tandem instructor were close to zero.
No. When people use and ignore the same procedures the odds are all pretty much the same.
I would hope, at the very least, that my mistake might at least, somehow lower those odds.
It WOULDN'T, Scott. These mistakes NEVER lower odds.
The reason idiots suffer and die from and perpetrate these disasters is because they're relying on their memories of something they may or may not have done a minute or two before. They're gonna suck a lot worse when you move the time up to days, weeks, months, years.
Imagining any more pilots facing such a situation - not to mention those harmed (which really needs to be mentioned)...
Yeah. I'm glad I'm not the only one who noticed that it, rather conspicuously, WASN'T mentioned.
...is not a very happy thought.
Stay with that unhappy thought - EVERY time and within two seconds of EVERY launch.
This is what I think we all (including Jon?) hope comes as a result of this trauma - That the hang gliding community learns from this dire situation.
Why should it? It's never shown the slightest indication from learning anything from all the other fatalities. Bill Murray should do another movie and call it "Wake-Up Call".
That someone who may have made the same mistake, WON'T - because they heard about and learned from Jon's situation.
Learned what? Learning is measured by observable behavior changes. What do we see happening after any of these newsworthy plummets?
That every tandem hang glider pilot will look at their student/passenger and see their importance as a person before seeing them as so many $ tickets to ride.
You think that Lenami died because Jon didn't see his passenger as anything beyond expendable payload?
How does that hypothesis account for Kunio Yoshimura and the scores of other solos who've had really bad days for the same reason?
This is totally useless rot, Scott.
We are human and make mistakes. This is true and unavoidable. But we aren't in this alone and we aren't all likely to make the same mistake at the same time. So, if we think we may or could make a mistake, ask for someone else's help, perspective or opinion before taking that irrevocable next step.
BULLSHIT. DO THE FUCKING HOOK-IN CHECK - EVERY TIME.
Don't THINK you MAY or COULD make the mistake before taking that irrevocable next step. Assume you ARE MAKING IT. Then do something to make sure you're not.
If Jon Orders happened to read this I would want him to know that his situation has caused me to think as constructively as I can about ways to avoid a reoccurrence of this tragedy. I think the effect has been the same with many of us. We are looking for solutions.
You didn't hear a word I was saying to you on this in 2009 and you're not hearing any of the people on the Davis and Jack Shows who have their shit together on this and are saying the EXACT SAME THING NOW.
Get your shit together, Scott. Then come back and post after you've resigned from being part of the problem and become part of the solution.