http://groups.yahoo.com/group/skysailingtowing/message/8147
Payout Line Strength?
Miller Stroud - 2012/04/24 18:54:23 UTC
My thoughts have always been that static towing in general is an out of date method for the exact reasons you stated, one cannot control the pressures consistantly with anything other than perfectly smooth conditions...
And this differs from aerotowing how?
With the introduction of payout winches I put static towing right there with an old 18 foot standard hang glider, assuming of course anything over a hundred feet of altitude is your goal. Stretch may make it safer but I won't go as far as to say it makes it safe enough!
No. It makes it more dangerous. PERIOD.
Once your "stretch is stretched", you're back to nothing again, not to mention the projectile mode with a line break.
- And what happens with all that stored energy if - by some miracle - your weak link DOESN'T break?
- So why are you saying that "stretch may make it safer"?
Just my thoughts of what is acceptable for myself.
Fuck that. Physics doesn't give a rat's ass about personalities.
Answer me this. If you had your choice, would you rather static tow or payout winch tow? If you answer payout winch, then your compromizing yourself based upon what equipment is available. I'm not attacking anyone, just expressing some of my life's observations.
Yeah, we've had quite a few deaths to lend credence to that observation.
Dan Hartowicz - 2012/04/24 19:11:42 UTC
OOOOH, ouch! Insults, static towing is like rogollo standard technology! C'mon! It sounds like you have not static towed much. I have thousands of safe tows, many hundreds of them being tandem. Anywhere from 0-30 mph headwinds, 0-90 degree of cross winds. 7/10ths of a mile roads to 4 mile roads. Mostly 2000 feet of altitude and some 4000 feet plus.
- Not crashing over the course of thousands of tows is not great evidence that they're SAFE.
- We're not concerned about road lengths or altitudes much over two hundred feet.
I, at no time on a static line am 5-50 feet over the car I am attached too.
That's wonderful. Now tell us about all the carnage that's resulted from payout gliders being five to fifty feet over the car you're attached to.
P.S. You're not ATTACHED to the car on payout. You're attached to a line coming off of a constant tension winch. If you wanna be attached to a car - try static towing.
People ask me "What is the safest method of flying a hang glider" (Pay out, static tow, aero tow, ridge soaring in higher winds, mountain launchs, boat towing)?
How 'bout we run this one by Zack?
Zack C - 2011/03/04 05:29:28 UTC
I now feel platform launching is the safest way to get a hang glider into the air (in the widest range of conditions). You get away from the ground very quickly and don't launch until you have plenty of airspeed and excellent control.
I tell them what I have witnessed to be fact.
Bullshit. These issues aren't determined by watching whatever happens to be in front of one and making statements.
Whatever they are most experienced with.
Yeah? I'd hazard a guess at this point that people are WAY more likely to get mangled and killed on the flavor of towing with which they're most experienced than on something else. And that includes owners and staff of aerotow operations and they were probably a lot more experienced with aero than platform.
You show me ANY type of flying and I will shoot holes in it on how many things can go wrong.
How much effort have you made to plug any holes or even adopt the plugs that other people have provided? Just kidding.
I flew my static system next to seven payout tow teams in Arizona years ago, I got higher, faster, and my vehicle was back at launch reeled in in less time. I fly both ways, but I like that I can safely look around more on a 2000-3000 foot static line with less possibility of occilation than on a payout system. Each system has its good and bad points. I usually prefer static.
Fine. But cite some incidents - or even some reasonable scenarios - resulting from people launching on payout.
I never stated that you cannot control pressure with static in unstable air. I said it is easier with at least SOME polypro, or a line with some give to it.
You're getting a smoother feel - but your control of the tension (and thus glider) sucks.
Otherwise if you tow into a thermal you have to get a car doing 30 mph to stop its 4000-5000 pounds down to 10 mph in one second.
WHY? OR WHAT?
- So you don't blow your idiot fucking weak link?
- Why can't you just let the glider climb like in aerotow?
- If the tension needs to be dumped in a second why can't the pilot do it?
That is where the payout system shines.
The payout shines at liftoff and initial climbout.
Each system demands a different criteria in training a driver.
Why?
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=2467
weak links
Jim Rooney - 2007/08/01 13:47:23 UTC
Whatever's going on back there, I can fix it by giving you the rope.
Doesn't sound all that complicated to me.
All our pilots, 30-50, learned how to drive, and only on the most thermic turbulent days did they say it was difficult. I am sure you could learn and do it safely and change your opinion.