Weak links
- Tad Eareckson
- Posts: 9161
- Joined: 2010/11/25 03:48:55 UTC
Re: Weak links
Been talking to Joe Street via email the past couple days and in the course composing my last one it something obvious occurred to me regarding Luis's situation - which was very similar to:
- 1996/07/25 - Dave Farkas / Bill Bennett / Mike Del Signore
- 2005/09/03 - Gary Solomon / Arlan Birkett / Jeremiah Thompson
He was early/slow coming off the cart and never got the glider under control - yet was able to stay level with the tug up to twenty meters.
He should've stayed skimming and level - regardless of what the tug was doing - until he:
- forced the tug back down; or
- had enough speed to safely:
-- climb out
-- abort
-- get dumped
A huge part of our sport is now being dictated to us by the people who control the tugs and their lackeys:
- SOPs
- instruction
- release systems
- front and back end weak links
- decisions in the interest of our safety
- what does and doesn't appear in the magazine
- who is and isn't permitted to:
-- fly
-- participate in mainstream forums
Gliders still get to have some say in the matter of climb rate.
Also... Tow site:
http://centre.france3.fr/sites/regions_france3/files/styles/top_big/public/assets/images/2013/07/22/accident_42.jpg?itok=Ck9fOxFj
48°13'01.26" N 001°29'47.64" E
Plug the coordinates into Google Earth, go to Street View, and look around. There wasn't a whole lot in the area to restrict the tug from maneuvering in whatever direction would've best suited a glider at any given moment. Hard to imagine a much better environment in which to deal with an emergency.
- 1996/07/25 - Dave Farkas / Bill Bennett / Mike Del Signore
- 2005/09/03 - Gary Solomon / Arlan Birkett / Jeremiah Thompson
He was early/slow coming off the cart and never got the glider under control - yet was able to stay level with the tug up to twenty meters.
He should've stayed skimming and level - regardless of what the tug was doing - until he:
- forced the tug back down; or
- had enough speed to safely:
-- climb out
-- abort
-- get dumped
A huge part of our sport is now being dictated to us by the people who control the tugs and their lackeys:
- SOPs
- instruction
- release systems
- front and back end weak links
- decisions in the interest of our safety
- what does and doesn't appear in the magazine
- who is and isn't permitted to:
-- fly
-- participate in mainstream forums
Gliders still get to have some say in the matter of climb rate.
Also... Tow site:
http://centre.france3.fr/sites/regions_france3/files/styles/top_big/public/assets/images/2013/07/22/accident_42.jpg?itok=Ck9fOxFj
48°13'01.26" N 001°29'47.64" E
Plug the coordinates into Google Earth, go to Street View, and look around. There wasn't a whole lot in the area to restrict the tug from maneuvering in whatever direction would've best suited a glider at any given moment. Hard to imagine a much better environment in which to deal with an emergency.
Re: Weak links
Tad,
have you some links about
- 1996/07/25 - Dave Farkas / Bill Bennett / Mike Del Signore
- 2005/09/03 - Gary Solomon / Arlan Birkett / Jeremiah Thompson
I already found http://m.ozreport.com/9.182.0 about Arlan and don't find the Guy Denney report as announced..
Nothing about Bill Benett..
Thx
have you some links about
- 1996/07/25 - Dave Farkas / Bill Bennett / Mike Del Signore
- 2005/09/03 - Gary Solomon / Arlan Birkett / Jeremiah Thompson
I already found http://m.ozreport.com/9.182.0 about Arlan and don't find the Guy Denney report as announced..
Nothing about Bill Benett..
Thx
- Tad Eareckson
- Posts: 9161
- Joined: 2010/11/25 03:48:55 UTC
Re: Weak links
Sorry to be slow getting back to you. There were two posts:
http://www.kitestrings.org/post2523.html#p2523
http://www.kitestrings.org/post2524.html#p2524
on which I needed to do a lot of editing with respect to references/attributions/links relevant to the 1996/07/25 and 2005/09/03 double fatals before bringing more attention to them.
Both are transcriptions of traffic from the TUGS group from two and a half years ago when I was going after Tracy. You can skim/search them for info on the crashes.
Both of them were precipitated by tug drivers who climbed above the glider and stayed there until the front end weak links blew.
And, no there probably is no Guy Denney report that anybody besides Joe Gregor and maybe one or two other Industry sleazebags got to see.
USHGA / the Industry REALLY doesn't want good information about tandem crashes coming out 'cause...
- They make most of their money on tourist tandem rides they're advertising to be as safe as Ferris wheels.
- It's difficult to pin everything on some bozo who had no clue what he was doing 'cause the Pilot In Command was always one of these USHGA certified and endorsed God's Gift to Aviation professional pilot types like Rooney.
I'll have a little more to say on the 2005/09/03 incident in the near future.
I don't imagine you have any better intelligence on Sara Reynaud's condition than anybody else outside the family but if you hear anything please keep us up to speed.
Didn't realize that Luis Rizo was a classical composer of some renown. What a waste.
Oh well, at least he gave us a dramatic illustration of how deadly aerotowing can be when two or three small mistakes are lined up even when Mother Nature isn't capitalizing on the opportunity.
http://www.kitestrings.org/post2523.html#p2523
http://www.kitestrings.org/post2524.html#p2524
on which I needed to do a lot of editing with respect to references/attributions/links relevant to the 1996/07/25 and 2005/09/03 double fatals before bringing more attention to them.
Both are transcriptions of traffic from the TUGS group from two and a half years ago when I was going after Tracy. You can skim/search them for info on the crashes.
Both of them were precipitated by tug drivers who climbed above the glider and stayed there until the front end weak links blew.
And, no there probably is no Guy Denney report that anybody besides Joe Gregor and maybe one or two other Industry sleazebags got to see.
USHGA / the Industry REALLY doesn't want good information about tandem crashes coming out 'cause...
- They make most of their money on tourist tandem rides they're advertising to be as safe as Ferris wheels.
- It's difficult to pin everything on some bozo who had no clue what he was doing 'cause the Pilot In Command was always one of these USHGA certified and endorsed God's Gift to Aviation professional pilot types like Rooney.
I'll have a little more to say on the 2005/09/03 incident in the near future.
I don't imagine you have any better intelligence on Sara Reynaud's condition than anybody else outside the family but if you hear anything please keep us up to speed.
Didn't realize that Luis Rizo was a classical composer of some renown. What a waste.
Oh well, at least he gave us a dramatic illustration of how deadly aerotowing can be when two or three small mistakes are lined up even when Mother Nature isn't capitalizing on the opportunity.
- Tad Eareckson
- Posts: 9161
- Joined: 2010/11/25 03:48:55 UTC
Re: Weak links
Joe Gregor - 2006/01
Hang Gliding Accident Report
It is with deep regret that I must report the following three fatalities for 2005:
INITIAL REPORT:
Date/Time: 2005/09/03, approximately 18:30
Location: Cushing Field, Illinois
Pilot: 47-year-old male, H4, advanced tandem instructor, AT administrator
Equipment:
- Glider: North Wing T2
- Harness: tandem over/under design
- Helmet: unknown
Weather: unknown
A highly experienced tandem pilot and student crashed while launching via aerotow. Initial witness reports indicate that the glider entered a lockout and was disconnected from the tug in a non-flying attitude at approximately 250' AGL due to a failure of the towline. The accident glider dove steeply to the ground, impacting before showing any sign of recovery to controlled flight. The instructor and student died on impact.
- THINK, Joe... Where's it say anybody MUST report fatalities?It is with deep regret that I must report the following three fatalities for 2005:
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=25321
Stop the Stupids at the USHPA BOD meeting
- Deep regrets and reporting fatalities is SO Twentieth Century. Now we just stuff the magazine full of cool people having loads of unbelievable fun! Nobody wants to get into hang gliding and hear a lot of downer stuff about people getting hurt and killed and screaming kids watching dad plummet from his glider 'cause USHGA won't teach or allow anyone to even mention hook-in checks.Mark G. Forbes - 2011/09/30 23:21:56 UTC
Here's how it really works:
- Member submits an accident report. Could be the pilot who had the accident, or some other witness.
- Accident report is sent to Tim to maintain legal privilege. Tim reviews the report and determines whether there's significant legal risk associated with it. He may redact certain parts (personally identifiable information, etc.) if in his opinion exposure of that information poses a risk to us. If the report is very risky, he may decide that it can't be shared further, and will notify the ED about it. He may also notify our insurers if he sees a potential for a claim, as is normal practice for any incident where we are aware of such a potential.
- If you must report unpleasantness report on broken arms and write five page discussions on how people should perfect their flare timing by spending more time on the training hill, attending landing clinics, and reading five page discussions on how people should perfect their flare timing. Glider folk just LOVE that sorta thing.
- Yeah Joe. THREE fatalities:
-- 2005/09/03 - Arlan Birkett
-- 2005/09/03 - Jeremiah Thompson
-- 2005/09/25 - Saito Hiroshi
-- 2005/10/01 - Bill Priday
No, wait! That's FOUR!!! Oops. No, Jeremiah was just a tandem student. Those don't really count - liability issues and all that sort of bother... Sorry for the interruption. Do continue.
It's been close to three months now, Joe. When are we gonna get the FINAL REPORT? What information that you couldn't get collected and analyzed in the space of three months are you expecting to be seeing in the near future?INITIAL REPORT:
Or is the idea to feed us this piddling little load of useless watered down rot on the pretense that next month we'll get something of some actual substance - then just do nothing for the next few years by which time nobody will remember that anything even happened?
Isn't that where Mike Haas bought it a little over fourteen months prior? Remember Mike? He was the guy you determined made no attempt to release from tow prior to the weak link break as the gate was found closed on the Wallaby-style tow release. Also obviously made no attempt to recover from the unusual attitude as he impacted the ground in a steep dive and suffered fatal injuries due to blunt trauma. Some folk got it, some don't.Location: Cushing Field, Illinois
So if the pilot was a 47-year-old male, H4, advanced tandem instructor, AT administrator how come how come Mike Van Kuiken says he saw that...Pilot: 47-year-old male, H4, advanced tandem instructor, AT administrator
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=865
Tandem pilot and passenger death
...Jeremiah was doing the takeoff right from the start and he watched him get pretty low on the tow as the tug crossed the road at the end of the runway? Who's flying this thing? Was there a designated pilot in command?Mike Van Kuiken - 2005/10/10 18:44:27 UTC
I watched the glider come almost straight down from about 250 feet. I saw that Jeremiah was doing the takeoff right from the start and I watched him get pretty low on the tow as the tug crossed the road at the end of the runway.
Whatsamattah? Figure it's too legally dangerous to dump it on the student this time? Real good idea to draw as little attention as possible to him?
So there was a tandem glider and a tandem over/under design harness but just one helmet - and you don't know what it was.Equipment:
- Glider: North Wing T2
- Harness: tandem over/under design
- Helmet: unknown
- Whoa, DUDE! Quest doesn't know what the weather was doing at Groveland on the afternoon of 2013/02/02 either - but they strongly suspect invisible dust devils were coming through. I'm starting to think there was an invisible dust devil involved in this one too. Probably an evening dust devil - those are the worst kind 'cause nobody ever expects them.Weather: unknown
- Ya think it might be a good idea for us to figure out what the weather's doing BEFORE we launch gliders into it instead of still having no fucking clue what the weather was doing after two people get - sorry - a valuable member of our closely knit / deeply inbred flying community gets totaled?
- Took me about a minute and a half to go online and find out what the weather was doing that day, motherfucker.
OH!!! So there WAS a student involved - even though we don't count him...A highly experienced tandem pilot and student...
http://ozreport.com/9.182
Arlan
...amongst the fatalities. So did he have a(n):Nathan Martin - 2005/09/03
Jeremiah was in his twenties, I believe, and was thought to be a slick pilot by other instructors and was expected to solo.
- age
- gender
- rating
- experience level
- unknown helmet
- position on the over/under harness
Oh. It was an aerotow. I was wondering how a glider managed to get to 250 feet with the terrain as flat as it is in that part of the country. So there was probably a tug involved somewhere near the other end of the string....crashed while launching via aerotow.
- So how come there's no "Tug: unknown" to go along with the all important "Helmet: unknown" listing? Is there any reason we don't want much attention drawn to the tug?
- You've made a point of telling us that "the pilot" was a highly experienced 47-year-old male, Hang Four, advanced tandem instructor, AT administrator. So the experience level and qualifications of the tug pilot are totally irrelevant to this situation?
INITIAL witness reports?Initial witness reports...
- Aren't you supposed to put things on hold for five days or so so's USHGA's lawyer can decide what's best for people to have witnessed - and not witnessed - and get the stories appropriately coordinated?
- INITIAL witness reports means there were LATER witness reports. And that means there are reports you're not telling us about.
- How many witnesses were there and what percentage of them are we hearing from?
- Wouldn't the tug pilot have been a fairly important witness? How come we don't have an account from him? When you were taking statements from initial witnesses did he tell you that his attorney had instructed him to make no comment?
- Didn't it hafta exit the Cone of Safety before it entered the lockout?...indicate that the glider entered a lockout...
- Why did it exit the Cone of Safety?
- Was it using a fin?
- Why not?
- Was it safe for it to be flying in unknown evening weather conditions?
- Did anybody see any invisible dust devils? No, wait. They're invisible - so nobody can see them. Duh. An invisible dust devil sure would go a long way towards explaining stuff though.
- Which direction?
- If the glider was locking out wouldn't it have been a better idea for the highly experienced, 47-year-old male, H4, advanced tandem instructor, AT administrator pilot to blow the release instead of waiting for the towline to pop? Might not that have mitigated the lockout and maybe some of the following unpleasantness?
-- So how come there's no "Release: unknown" entry?
-- Or did you make the mistake of finding out that he had a Quallaby-style release and figure that if you said:
again after so short an interval since the previous fatal crash at the same operation and this time the pilot was a highly experienced 47-year-old male H4 advanced tandem instructor AT administrator that people might start considering that the problem wasn't so much a clueless bozo who thought he could fix a bad thing and didn't want to start over as a total piece of shit "release" that's totally inoperable in an emergency and is only velcroed onto the right downtube as a placebo?There is no evidence that the pilot made an attempt to release from tow prior to the weak link break, the gate was found closed on the Wallaby-style tow release.
- The deal is that if you ever went so far as to identify an ACTUAL deadly problem it would be understood that the whole fucking Industry is just an "accident" waiting to happen, the happenings are occurring at regular internals, and nobody is ever doing shit about them, right Joe?
What attitude WAS it in? Floating? Crouching? Running? Swimming? Mating?...and was disconnected from the tug in a non-flying attitude...
Ya know what 250 feet MSL is at Cushing field? 390 feet underground. We can probably figure out that you mean AGL without you saying AGL. But I guess the more you pad this "report" with professional/official sounding crap the less people will notice you're not saying anything - and specifically what it is you're not saying....at approximately 250' AGL...
Lessee......due to a failure of the towline.
- Under FAA aerotow regulations the:
-- minimum allowable glider weak link was 414 pounds
-- maximum allowable tug weak link for that glider weak link would've been 518 pounds
- Under USHGA aerotow requirements the minimum possible towline was supposed to have been 829 pounds.
So how could the towline have failed?
- How come Mike Van Kuiken says that the WEAK LINK broke from the TOW PLANE SIDE and...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=865
Tandem pilot and passenger death
...the towline was found underneath the wreck still connected by the weak link which was supposed to blow at less than the front end weak link and no more than half the towline?Mike Van Kuiken - 2005/10/13 19:47:26 UTC
The weak link broke from the tow plane side. The towline was found underneath the wreck, and attached to the glider by the weaklink. The glider basically fell on the towline.
- How come you're not telling us at what point the towline failed?
- Even if the towline failed at before the front end weak link the glider wouldn't have fallen on it 'cause most of it would've stayed with the tug 'cause if a towline WERE to fail before any fishing line it would fail near the glider end tow ring 'cause that's the end that gets the most dragging and abuse.
- And I've NEVER heard of an AT towline breaking so I'm finding it highly suspicious that the one time I do it's results in a double fatal.
- You're reporting that the towline failed 'cause that's a lot easier to get away with than reporting that the system included a component deliberately designed to dump the entire towline well inside the range of normal operating tensions.
Yeah Joe. It's been published that "the cable snapped". That's what lotsa people believe, that's not a bad story to stick to. And then we can publish a bullshit advisory...Chicago Sun-Times - 2005/10/06
But two hundred feet into that ascent, the cable snapped, and the hang glider plummeted to the ground, smashing to pieces and instantly killing Thompson and Birkett.
On Wednesday, Thompson's family filed a negligence lawsuit against the company, demanding unspecified damages but also hoping to find out how the crash happened.
"They're two hundred feet in the air, and while normally they would glide to the ground, this hang glider nose-dived to the ground," attorney Matthew Rundio said. "We need to find out why that happened."
http://www.ushpa.aero/advisory.asp?id=1
Safety Notice
"Should the tandem glider become unattached..." For the love o' God don't say anything about a weak link blowing. A weak link blowing is ALWAYS a GOOD thing - nothing at all like "becoming unattached".HG Tandem Aerotow Operations - 2006/03/15
If the pilot of the tandem glider finds that he/she is too low behind the tug and slow enough that the glider will not climb without pushing out pass trim, then the pilot should pull in and release rather than trying to push out and climb to the tug altitude. Though pushing out to climb to the tug altitude has been a common practice usually accomplished without incident, there is a deep underlying danger in doing this. Should the tandem glider become unattached from the tug during this maneuver...
The ACCIDENT glider? And here I was reading this fatality report thinking this was gonna be the and-they-all-lived-happily-ever-after glider.The accident glider...
Oh. So the accident glider wasn't being controlled at that point....dove steeply to the ground, impacting before showing any sign of recovery to controlled flight.
Lemme show you a less pretentious way of writing that...
The people representing the most convenient account of this disaster state that at 250 feet the glider locked out, blew the towline, and went down like a brick.
- But only one REAL person was killed.The instructor and student died on impact.
- Damn. If only we could find out what kind of helmet the pilot was using. Then we could cross it off of our list of helmets good for diving steeply to the ground and impacting before showing any sign of recovery to controlled flight.
Fuckin' sleazebag.
- Tad Eareckson
- Posts: 9161
- Joined: 2010/11/25 03:48:55 UTC
Re: Weak links
http://www.kitestrings.org/post4839.html#p4839
4strings release
Surface towing for teaching
Surface towing for teaching
4strings release
4strings release
Even using this 1.0 G lockout protector - 6.7 percent under Rooney strength and near the bottom end of the legal range - he wound up going in the opposite direction and getting badly injured. He was lucky he wasn't killed.
Don't expect to be able to use a Rooney Link as an emergency release much more than about zero times and enjoy a hang gliding career that finishes in the black - regardless of how much bullshit you've gotten away with when you've had a couple hundred feet to burn.
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-bRrpHNa68iY/UQ6Pv9gRZyI/AAAAAAAAjTg/Hc22bx5122Q/s2048/20943781_BG1.jpg
4strings release
http://www.kitestrings.org/post4837.html#p4837deltaman - 2013/07/27 18:32:14 UTC
This we, a friend had part of his arm broken after a lockout.
Launch by cart with side wind. He didn't wait enough before to release the cart and banked immediately on the opposite of the wind.
He was in a lockout, at 15m above the ground.
The trike was in acceleration phase.
He had a wichard and didn't release.
The weaklink (110kg) broke.
He did a U-turn and fly downwind before to be stopped by a hangar and broke his elbow (compound fracture of olecrane).
Surface towing for teaching
http://www.kitestrings.org/post4842.html#p4842deltaman - 2013/07/27 17:26:53 UTC
A student died this we. He was surface towing by scooter with a forwarding pulley in the ground.
The student, 43yo, didn't release and started a lockout.
Surface towing for teaching
http://www.kitestrings.org/post4844.html#p4844Tad Eareckson - 2013/07/27 21:11:55 UTC
Try to find out what the weak link was. We need it to be light. Then we can show how an aero guy at under fifty feet was blown off by a two G weak link and did way better than a scooter guy at under fifty feet who wasn't blown off soon enough / at all by his three quarter G training weak link and died.
4strings release
http://www.kitestrings.org/post4846.html#p4846deltaman - 2013/07/28 08:08:51 UTC
It was a Laminar 13ST.
The pilot is around 75-80kg clipped-in.
110kg weaklink in the towline.
4strings release
Spin revision...Tad Eareckson - 2013/07/28 14:03:02 UTC
Damn. That helps the enemy.
- 1.0 times actual flying weight
- 0.9 times max flying weight
Even using this 1.0 G lockout protector - 6.7 percent under Rooney strength and near the bottom end of the legal range - he wound up going in the opposite direction and getting badly injured. He was lucky he wasn't killed.
Don't expect to be able to use a Rooney Link as an emergency release much more than about zero times and enjoy a hang gliding career that finishes in the black - regardless of how much bullshit you've gotten away with when you've had a couple hundred feet to burn.
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-bRrpHNa68iY/UQ6Pv9gRZyI/AAAAAAAAjTg/Hc22bx5122Q/s2048/20943781_BG1.jpg
- Tad Eareckson
- Posts: 9161
- Joined: 2010/11/25 03:48:55 UTC
Re: Weak links
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=31432
Free* weak link tensile testing.
Free* weak link tensile testing.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjRrYAOnqqwOrion Price - 2013/03/16 00:31:26 UTC
I have a 10kN (2,200lbf) tensile tester at my disposal.
Mail me your links, and I will test them.
The * after the "free" is a stipulation. Disclose all relevant information about the link, and let me publish the data for everyone to enjoy. That's it. All it costs you is a envelope. Want to try a different knot? What to try a new material? What happens when you use two links? What about old links? You will know. Tensile tests like this are much more telling than just a material's failure or ultimate point.
I'm a west coast foot launch guy, but I've got about 20 tows at enjoy field and whitewater combined. I've seen your guy's testing contraptions. I've also glossed over Tad's color ASCII text batshit insane manifesto. But I got turned off when it was clear he doesn't know the difference between acceleration, mass, and what a forces are. Maybe my machine can paint a better picture for the tow world. Also in the background of that pic is a SEM, it will be interesting to see the failure up close.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stress%E2%80%93strain_curve
Send them to:
OP C/O
SHGA
P.O. Box 922303
Sylmar, CA 91392
Also allow several weeks for processing. Label your links clearly.
- Tad Eareckson
- Posts: 9161
- Joined: 2010/11/25 03:48:55 UTC
Re: Weak links
Zapata...
- The best of the best.
- The top tug and glider pilots on the planet flying the best XC conditions on the planet.
- Flights of up to 475 miles.
- Decades of perfecting aerotowing through the tireless efforts of the best minds in the business.
And the ONLY thing we have to keep the glider safe while it climbs through the kill zone is a piece of fishing line...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=24846
Is this a joke ?
...that won't allow the glider to stay behind the tug unless the air is very smooth and the turns are very gradual - and can be COUNTED ON to blow at the worst possible time, when the glider is climbing hard in a near stall situation.
- The best of the best.
- The top tug and glider pilots on the planet flying the best XC conditions on the planet.
- Flights of up to 475 miles.
- Decades of perfecting aerotowing through the tireless efforts of the best minds in the business.
And the ONLY thing we have to keep the glider safe while it climbs through the kill zone is a piece of fishing line...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=24846
Is this a joke ?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjRrYAOnqqwDavis Straub - 2011/08/28 15:26:28 UTC
Then again, Russell Brown had us double up behind him after six breaks in a row at Zapata. We couldn't figure out why we had so many breaks so quickly. Maybe just coincidence.
...that won't allow the glider to stay behind the tug unless the air is very smooth and the turns are very gradual - and can be COUNTED ON to blow at the worst possible time, when the glider is climbing hard in a near stall situation.
- Tad Eareckson
- Posts: 9161
- Joined: 2010/11/25 03:48:55 UTC
Re: Weak links
I did this load o' crap:
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
A tumble at very low altitude
http://www.kitestrings.org/post3634.html#p3634
while the ink was still wet. But one hatchet job isn't NEARLY enough. So, while referring back so's to avoid excessive redundancy - to the extent that that's possible anyway...
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3107
I have a tandem rating!!!
More on Zapata and weak link
Is there any chance that we could use a better or, hell, equally crappy but DIFFERENT set of towing equipment and possibly achieve better results? What have we got to lose? The results couldn't have been any worse so different results would - by definition - be BETTER results. Right...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
- was having any difficulties towing the glider or that anything the least bit unexpected happened...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
-- had any serious problems until his standard 130 pound test Pilot In Command decided to increase the safety of the towing operation when Zack's Moyes Xtralite was standing on its tail.
So how come you're even bringing that issue up?
Did you happen to notice how far forward of the hang point he had set the anchor point for the bridle? That can have a pretty significant effect on the pitch trim - as I'm quite sure all you top notch aerotow professionals all well know.
- You've identified yourself and the dead passenger. How come you're not identifying the...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
- Is that what the manufacturer recommends? What's it say in the owner's manual?
- The manufacturer is Moyes.
-- They also manufacture the Dragonfly tug that was being used.
-- The Dragonfly uses a two point bridle with the upper attachment being an extended tow mast which aligns the towline with the line of thrust to minimize pitch control problems associated with tow tension.
-- Shouldn't the glider also be rigged with a two point bridle to align the towline / line of thrust with the glider's center of drag? Wouldn't eliminating the upper attachment make it a lot more difficult to keep the glider from pitching up if it got blasted by a thermal and/or there was a surge in towline tension?
-- I mean, the glider's already pitched up pretty high solely as a consequence of being aerotowed - and an abrupt loss of that tension...
- THIS:
- Is there a standard glider for which this standard 130 pound test weak link is most suitable? Or does it work equally well on all gliders regardless of flying weight?
- What's its purpose?
- I hear its primary purpose is to...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=24534
It's a wrap
-- So was Zack experiencing tow forces become greater than desirable? Doesn't really...
-- How come neither he nor his Pilot In Command made any effort to release?
-- Was there a lockout?
-- How 'bout a malfunction of equipment or whatever?
-- Was the passenger getting too far out of whack?
-- The glider sustained very little damage so I guess the standard 130 pound test weak link did pretty good on that score but it didn't do too well at saving the hang glider pilot.
- Are you sure it tests at 130 pounds? Mark thinks...
http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=28290
Report about fatal accident at Quest Air Hang Gliding
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=31052
Poll on weaklinks
- Are you sure it wasn't Wrapped and Tied 130 pound Greenspot? That's the loop Russell recommends and those suckers are good for 260 pounds. I'm thinking that's not a great idea 'cause you might get REALLY too far out of whack.
- Why did the weak link break?
- At what point did Zack start having a really bad day?
- How did Zack's angle of attack a millisecond after the weak link broke compare to his angle of attack a millisecond BEFORE the weak link broke?
What are you saying the glider did, Paul? Where were you and Lauren?
What did the eyewitnesses say about invisible dust devils?
http://ozreport.com/12.081
Weaklinks - the HGFA rules
http://www.jm2c.com/hangola/2005/0125.htm
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
- Zack was using the "pro tow" method where the tow line is attached directly to a bridle on the pilot's harness and is not attached to the glider at all
- a standard 130 pound test weak link was being used
- the weak link broke as the nose of the glider pitched up quickly to a very high angle of attack
But we should be fine speculating about invisible dust devils. Those have always been fair game when sleazy flight park operators are desperately seeking wiggle room.
Have you ever felt in danger of a STALL??? Did you talk this over with your bitch?
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3380
Lauren and Paul in Zapata
Weak link question
http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=28290
Report about fatal accident at Quest Air Hang Gliding
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=32824
Weaklink testing
- I've witnessed countless people:
-- whipstalling their gliders to dead stops in light switchy conditions
-- skipping preflight sidewire load tests and hook-in checks
-- launching with brake lever release actuators velcroed to their downtubes
with no serious problems.
- Have you:
-- witnessed countable others having weak link breaks with serious problems?
-- ever heard or read about anyone having a weak link break with a serious problem?
- Would you not consider Lauren's little romp...
- Couldn't Zack have had a fairly serious problem just getting dumped by a weak link break and having to land in the thermal (or invisible dust devil) that popped the planes up? Sounds like the Pilot In Command...
- Can you conceive of an unlikely hypothetical situation in which a weak link break could result in a very serious problem?
- I know you didn't actually see it happen but you're reporting on Zack Marzec having a fairly serious problem after his weak link broke. Are you gonna discount the possibility that his serious problem might have had something to do with the weak link break because you've witnessed countless others have weak link breaks with no serious problems?
- WITH NO SERIOUS PROBLEMS?!?!?! Weak links function ONLY to PREVENT serious problems.
-- Saying that you've witnessed countless others have weak link breaks with no serious problems is like saying you've seen people doing strong launch runs and clearing their turns with no serious problems.
-- And Jim Keen-Intellect Rooney ASSURES us that it's physically impossible to have so much as a MINOR problem with a weak link break - just an inconvenience. You really should get together with him so he can make you understand that you're not actually seeing any minor problems resulting from standard 130 pound test weak link pops.
- So aren't you gonna tell us about some of the countless lives you seen saved when these countless weak link breaks you've witnessed have prevented low level lockouts with no serious problems? You must have countless really amazing stories. Maybe you put a collection of them up on Quest's website.
- Ever consider going to something heavier than the standard 130 pound test weak link to get the number of weak link breaks you've witnessed down to countable levels? Nah...
But if you really DO wanna shed some more light on this accident...
- Go up in smooth evening air with a pro toad bridle and a standard 130 pound test weak link.
- Pull the bar in at a hundred feet then shove it out hard to simulate Zack's climb.
- Wait for the standard 130 pound test weak link to pop. (Shouldn't take any more than a second or two.)
If the glider doesn't tailslide, whipstall, and tumble that'll be pretty good evidence to support your invisible dust devil hypothesis. (Have a couple of cameras running so we can have a productive discussion about the issue. And wear a good helmet - just in case.)
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
A tumble at very low altitude
back at:Paul Tjaden - 2013/02/07 23:47:58 UTC
Quest Air
Groveland, Florida
A few days ago I promised that I would write a more complete accident report regarding the tragic hang gliding accident we recently had at Quest Air resulting in the death of our good friend, Zach Marzec. I do want to warn you in advance that there will be no great revelations from what you already know. Many times Zach flew with a video camera which could have possibly told us more but on this occasion he did not.
The weather conditions seemed quite benign. It was a typical winter day in central Florida with sunny skies, moderate temperatures and a light south west wind. It was, however, a high pressure, dry air day that sometimes creates punchy conditions with small, tight, strong thermals versus the big fat soft ones that Florida is famous for. Time of day was approximately 3:00. None of these conditions were even slightly alarming or would have caused any concern about launching.
Zach Marzec was an advanced rated pilot who was a tandem instructor for Kitty Hawk Kites where he logged a huge number of aerotow flights. He was current (flying every day) and was flying his personal glider that he was very familiar with and had towed many times. Sorry, I do not have specific numbers of hours or flights logged but experience does not appear to have been an issue.
The glider was a Moyes Xtralite. This glider was a fairly old design. I believe the last ones built were in the mid 1990's, but it was in good, airworthy condition and rigged properly. I know of no reports that this glider is difficult to tow or has any deficiencies for aero towing but I am not an expert on it and have never flown one. The glider hit base tube first and sustained very little damage upon impact so it was easy to ascertain that the glider did not appear to have had any structural failure that would have caused the accident.
The tow aircraft was a Moyes Dragonfly with a 914 Rotax engine and was piloted by a highly experienced tow pilot. The tow line was approximately 250 feet long which is standard and Zach was using the "pro tow" method where the tow line is attached directly to a bridle on the pilot's harness and is not attached to the glider at all. A standard 130 pound test weak link was being used.
Another pilot had launched with no issues immediately before the accident. The launch started on the main runway at the north end (2,000 feet long) and was normal until at approximately 50 feet in altitude when the tow plane hit extremely strong lift elevating it quickly and abruptly. Because of the length of the tow line, it was a few seconds later when Zach's glider entered the same strong lift and he was at an estimated 100 to 150 feet in altitude at this time. When the lift/turbulence was encountered, the weak link on the tow line broke as the nose of the glider pitched up quickly to a very high angle of attack. Apparently, the glider stalled or possibly did a short tail slide and then stalled and then nosed down and tumbled. Eye witnesses said the glider tumbled twice and then struck the ground with the base tube low. Due to the extremely low altitude, there was no time for the pilot to deploy his reserve parachute.
Zach was conscious immediately after the accident but died in route to the hospital.
Beyond these facts anything else would be pure speculation. I have personally had numerous weak link breaks on tow, both low and high, after hitting turbulence and have never felt in danger of a tumble. I have witnessed countless others have weak link breaks with no serious problems. We train aero tow pilots how to handle this situation and I am certain that Zach had also encountered this situation many times before and knew how to react properly. Apparently, Zach simply hit strong low level turbulence, probably a dust devil that could not be seen due to the lack of dust in Florida, the nose went too high and he tumbled at a very low altitude.
Strong dust devils in Florida definitely do exist even though they are rare. My wife had a near miss when she encountered a severe dusty a couple years ago and I almost lost a brand new $18,000 ATOS VX when it was torn from its tie down and thrown upside down.
I wish I could shed more light on this accident but I am afraid this is all we know and probably will know. Zach was a great guy with an incredible outlook and zest for life. He will be sorely missed.
http://www.kitestrings.org/post3634.html#p3634
while the ink was still wet. But one hatchet job isn't NEARLY enough. So, while referring back so's to avoid excessive redundancy - to the extent that that's possible anyway...
We didn't need the video on this one to know EXACTLY what happened and why any more than we needed the card Jon Orders swallowed. Total fuckin' no brainer.Many times Zach flew with a video camera which could have possibly told us more but on this occasion he did not.
None of you goddam useless pieces of shit is EVER...None of these conditions were even slightly alarming or would have caused any concern about launching.
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3107
I have a tandem rating!!!
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3391Lauren Tjaden - 2008/03/23 22:20:15 UTC
When Jim got me locked out to the right, I couldn't keep the pitch of the glider with one hand for more than a second (the pressure was a zillion pounds, more or less), but the F'ing release slid around when I tried to hit it. The barrel release wouldn't work because we had too much pressure on it.
Anyhow, the tandem can indeed perform big wingovers, as I demonstrated when I finally got separated from the tug.
More on Zapata and weak link
...slightly alarmed about ANYTHING.Paul Tjaden - 2008/07/22 04:32:22 UTC
I have never had a lockout situation happen so quickly and dramatically and had no chance to release as I have always thought I could do.
In the proud tradition of such luminaries of the sport as Bill Bennett, Jamie Alexander, Rob Richardson, William Woloshyniuk, Arlan Birkett, and Jim Keen-Intellect Rooney.Zach Marzec was an advanced rated pilot who was a tandem instructor...
So in identical circumstances it sounds like we're all equally/totally fucked then - at a minimum. So it sounds like we're all just rolling dice every time we take off. UNLESS...Sorry, I do not have specific numbers of hours or flights logged but experience does not appear to have been an issue.
Is there any chance that we could use a better or, hell, equally crappy but DIFFERENT set of towing equipment and possibly achieve better results? What have we got to lose? The results couldn't have been any worse so different results would - by definition - be BETTER results. Right...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
...Kinsley?Kinsley Sykes - 2013/02/11 17:46:12 UTC
It's fine to want to work on better solutions to make us all safer by improving technology, it's ugly and inhuman to use the death of a really nice guy to advance your point... in case it wasn't obvious I agree with Bart and Jim, and no it's not a lack of english comprehension - he said there would have been a different outcome with a stronger weaklink.
As, of course, was his tow configuration. Accepted standard, good airworthy condition, rigged properly, no history of serious functionality / control issues.This glider was a fairly old design. I believe the last ones built were in the mid 1990's, but it was in good, airworthy condition and rigged properly.
Hey motherfucker... I didn't hear that Zack:I know of no reports that this glider is difficult to tow or has any deficiencies for aero towing...
- was having any difficulties towing the glider or that anything the least bit unexpected happened...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
...in the course of that tow.Mark Frutiger - 2013/02/08 19:12:21 UTC
Zack hit the lift a few seconds after I did. He was high and to the right of the tug and was out of my mirror when the weak ling broke. The load on the tug was not excessive as with a lockout, but I was not surprised when the weak link broke.
-- had any serious problems until his standard 130 pound test Pilot In Command decided to increase the safety of the towing operation when Zack's Moyes Xtralite was standing on its tail.
So how come you're even bringing that issue up?
So how come you didn't give Bill Fucking Moyes a buzz and get his take on the issue? Didn't wanna bother him with a matter this trivial?...but I am not an expert on it and have never flown one.
WHOA! And here we all were thinking that this fluke accident was probably the result of some kind of structural failure - as is so often the case just after a whipstall and just before the glider goes into a tumble. Thank you so very much for taking that off the table for us. Now maybe we can start focusing a little more on the whipstall.The glider hit base tube first and sustained very little damage upon impact so it was easy to ascertain that the glider did not appear to have had any structural failure that would have caused the accident.
Did you happen to notice how far forward of the hang point he had set the anchor point for the bridle? That can have a pretty significant effect on the pitch trim - as I'm quite sure all you top notch aerotow professionals all well know.
- Think he would've been experienced enough to know whether the extremely strong lift which was elevating him quickly and abruptly a few seconds before Zack's glider entered the same strong lift was a thermal or a dust devil?The tow aircraft was a Moyes Dragonfly with a 914 Rotax engine and was piloted by a highly experienced tow pilot.
- You've identified yourself and the dead passenger. How come you're not identifying the...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
...Pilot In Command of the glider that tumbled and killed his passenger? He's the guy who determines what bridle, releases, and weak link the glider will be permitted to fly with. So how come he's not the one writing the report?Jim Rooney - 2013/02/16 05:05:41 UTC
Ok, keyboard in hand.
I've got a bit of time, but I'm not going to write a dissertation... so either choose to try to understand what I'm saying, or (as is most often the case) don't.
I don't care.
Here's a little bit of bitter reality that ya'll get to understand straight off. I won't be sugar coating it, sorry.
You see, I'm on the other end of that rope.
I want neither a dead pilot on my hands or one trying to kill me.
And yes. It is my call. PERIOD.
On tow, I am the PIC.
Now, that cuts hard against every fiber of every HG pilot on the planet and I get that.
Absolutely no HG pilot likes hearing it. Not me, not no one. BUT... sorry, that's the way it is.
Accept it and move on.
Not only can you not change it, it's the law... in the very literal sense.
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
You weren't any more of a witness to what happened than Billo was. Isn't Mark a highly experienced enough tow pilot to report on things himself?Jim Rooney - 2013/03/07 18:24:58 UTC
You weren't there. You don't know.
All you have is the tug pilot report, who himself says he doesn't know... and HE WAS THERE... and he doesn't know.
OH!!! There WAS NO attachment to the keel.The tow line was approximately 250 feet long which is standard and Zach was using the "pro tow" method where the tow line is attached directly to a bridle on the pilot's harness and is not attached to the glider at all.
- Is that what the manufacturer recommends? What's it say in the owner's manual?
- The manufacturer is Moyes.
-- They also manufacture the Dragonfly tug that was being used.
-- The Dragonfly uses a two point bridle with the upper attachment being an extended tow mast which aligns the towline with the line of thrust to minimize pitch control problems associated with tow tension.
-- Shouldn't the glider also be rigged with a two point bridle to align the towline / line of thrust with the glider's center of drag? Wouldn't eliminating the upper attachment make it a lot more difficult to keep the glider from pitching up if it got blasted by a thermal and/or there was a surge in towline tension?
-- I mean, the glider's already pitched up pretty high solely as a consequence of being aerotowed - and an abrupt loss of that tension...
...could put the glider into a pretty nasty stall - or inconvenience (whatever term you Florida guys have for it). Did you ever wonder what might happen if the towline were to fail...Wills Wing / Blue Sky / Steve Wendt / Ryan Voight Productions - 2007/03
NEVER CUT THE POWER...
Reduce Gradually
Increase Gradually
...or there were a premature release?Manned Kiting
The Basic Handbook of Tow Launched Hang Gliding
Daniel F. Poynter
1974
"Never take your hands off the bar." - Tom Peghiny
"The greatest dangers are a rope break or a premature release." - Richard Johnson
REALLY?A standard 130 pound test weak link was being used.
- THIS:
standard 130 pound test weak link?Lauren Tjaden - 2003/12/14
This fall at Ridgely, I had a weak link break at maybe fifty feet. I thought I was going to have to land in the soybeans - the very tall soybeans - when I looked at my angle. But, my glider stalled quite dramatically almost instantly (hard not to stall when you have a break), and dove towards the ground (a bit disconcerting from so low).
- Is there a standard glider for which this standard 130 pound test weak link is most suitable? Or does it work equally well on all gliders regardless of flying weight?
- What's its purpose?
- I hear its primary purpose is to...
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=24534
It's a wrap
...release the glider and plane from each other when the tow forces become greater than desirable - whether that is due to a lockout or a malfunction of equipment or whatever - and save a glider, a tow pilot, or, more often, a hang glider pilot who does not get off of tow when he or she gets too far out of whack.Lauren Tjaden - 2011/08/01 02:01:06 UTC
For whomever asked about the function of a weak link, it is to release the glider and plane from each other when the tow forces become greater than desirable -- whether that is due to a lockout or a malfunction of equipment or whatever. This can save a glider, a tow pilot, or more often, a hang glider pilot who does not get off of tow when he or she gets too far out of whack.
-- So was Zack experiencing tow forces become greater than desirable? Doesn't really...
...sound much like it.Mark Frutiger - 2013/02/08 19:12:21 UTC
Zack hit the lift a few seconds after I did. He was high and to the right of the tug and was out of my mirror when the weak ling broke. The load on the tug was not excessive as with a lockout, but I was not surprised when the weak link broke.
-- How come neither he nor his Pilot In Command made any effort to release?
-- Was there a lockout?
-- How 'bout a malfunction of equipment or whatever?
-- Was the passenger getting too far out of whack?
-- The glider sustained very little damage so I guess the standard 130 pound test weak link did pretty good on that score but it didn't do too well at saving the hang glider pilot.
- Are you sure it tests at 130 pounds? Mark thinks...
http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=28290
Report about fatal accident at Quest Air Hang Gliding
...it's more. And he was right there when it happened - you weren't. Even Davis...Mark Frutiger - 2013/02/09 12:32:57 UTC
one strand is 130 lb, two strands, (one loop), is more.
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=31052
Poll on weaklinks
...isn't sure. And he's the one who writes the Greenspot regulations for all the competitions.Davis Straub - 2013/03/06 18:29:05 UTC
I'm thinking about doing a bit more testing as there seemed to be some disagreement around here about what the average breaking strength of a loop of Greenspot (or orange) weaklink was.
- Are you sure it wasn't Wrapped and Tied 130 pound Greenspot? That's the loop Russell recommends and those suckers are good for 260 pounds. I'm thinking that's not a great idea 'cause you might get REALLY too far out of whack.
Was he a pro? Did he report any invisible dust devils?Another pilot had launched with no issues immediately before the accident.
Probably an invisible dust devil. It's a miracle that he wasn't flipped upside down by it. But, of course, if he HAD been flipped upside down by it Zack would probably started working immediately on his bent pin barrel releases instead of just blithely flying on into this column of invisible spinning death.The launch started on the main runway at the north end (2,000 feet long) and was normal until at approximately 50 feet in altitude when the tow plane hit extremely strong lift elevating it quickly and abruptly.
Sounds like somebody's about to be inconvenienced.When the lift/turbulence was encountered, the weak link on the tow line broke as the nose of the glider pitched up quickly to a very high angle of attack.
- Why did the weak link break?
- At what point did Zack start having a really bad day?
- How did Zack's angle of attack a millisecond after the weak link broke compare to his angle of attack a millisecond BEFORE the weak link broke?
And this wasn't happening BEFORE the standard 130 pound test weak link broke. BEFORE the standard 130 pound test weak link increased the safety of the towing operation the glider was climbing.Apparently, the glider stalled or possibly did a short tail slide and then stalled and then nosed down and tumbled.
They got names?Eye witnesses said the glider tumbled twice...
What are you saying the glider did, Paul? Where were you and Lauren?
What did the eyewitnesses say about invisible dust devils?
Did his last words include any praises for the standard 130 pound test weak link...Zach was conscious immediately after the accident but died in route to the hospital.
http://ozreport.com/12.081
Weaklinks - the HGFA rules
...and Bobby Fucking-Genius Bailey's efforts to improve the safety of aerotowing by using a better weak link material? Or was his attitude something more along the lines of Lauren's...Davis Straub - 2008/04/22 14:47:00 UTC
At the 2008 Forbes Flatlands Greenspot for the first time was used as the standard weaklink material (thanks in large part to the efforts of Bobby Bailey). We applaud these efforts to improve the safety of aerotowing by using a better weaklink material.
http://www.jm2c.com/hangola/2005/0125.htm
...shocking display of ingratitude?Lauren Tjaden - 2005/01/21
I came off the cart smoothly, but at a hundred feet, started getting slammed. I tow lots, and I will tell you I have never felt anything like this before. Ginny leapt sideways and would go slack and then violently shudder. Jim hung onto the plane and I hung onto her basetube, but at four hundred feet my pussy-##s weak link broke. Great. Now I had to land in the monster that had just attacked the runway. My glider set me down neatly, but adrenaline was practically spilling out my eyeballs by then.
Right. And we CERTAINLY...Beyond these facts anything else would be pure speculation.
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
Jim Rooney - 2013/02/12 18:00:27 UTC
AT isn't new. This stuff's been worked on and worked over for years and thousands upon thousands of tows. I love all these egomaniacs that jump up and decide that they're going to "fix" things, as if no one else has ever thought of this stuff?
But back to the root of my anger... speculation.
...don't wanna open up that can of worms. At least not about the facts that:Jim Rooney - 2013/02/28 01:17:55 UTC
Well said Billo
I'm a bit sick of all the armchair experts telling me how my friend died.
Ah but hg'ers get so uppity when you tell them not to speculate.
- Zack was using the "pro tow" method where the tow line is attached directly to a bridle on the pilot's harness and is not attached to the glider at all
- a standard 130 pound test weak link was being used
- the weak link broke as the nose of the glider pitched up quickly to a very high angle of attack
But we should be fine speculating about invisible dust devils. Those have always been fair game when sleazy flight park operators are desperately seeking wiggle room.
That's fabulous, Paul. It's always so reassuring listening to total fucking douchebags talking about the feelings they've had using dangerous illegal equipment and getting away with it.I have personally had numerous weak link breaks on tow, both low and high, after hitting turbulence and have never felt in danger of a tumble.
Have you ever felt in danger of a STALL??? Did you talk this over with your bitch?
She seems to find these standard 130 pound test weak link pops a little more problematic than you do. And she's an Eminently Qualified Tandem Pilot. And I'm REALLY SURPRISED that someone as dedicated to aerotowing safety as Lauren is wasn't more involved in these discussions. I notice that she wasn't any too shy about warning people off from the deadly...Lauren Tjaden - 2003/12/14
But, my glider stalled quite dramatically almost instantly (hard not to stall when you have a break), and dove towards the ground (a bit disconcerting from so low).
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3380
Lauren and Paul in Zapata
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3600Lauren Tjaden - 2008/07/21 14:27:04 UTC
Yesterday I chased Paul again. The tow rope weak link broke when Paul locked out and the weak link he got from Tad did not break. Russell said it was about the worst he has ever had his tail pulled around. Anyhow, I would advise against those weak links, though Tad's barrel releases do seem better able to release under stress.
Weak link question
...Tad-O-Link because it's not very good at keeping fucking assholes flying in violent thermal conditions with one hand on the basetube and the other on the VG cord from locking out. You'd think she'd be a bit more chatty about...Lauren Tjaden - 2008/11/20 22:50:53 UTC
My only point here is that Tad's releases (by which she means weak links because the only thing Questies have to function as releases are loops of fishing line) have not been extensively tested, and at least in my experience with them, are not safe.
http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=28290
Report about fatal accident at Quest Air Hang Gliding
...the great tragedy of losing someone so young and vital right in her backyard - despite ensuring that he was using the best and most extensively tested lockout protectors in the scope of her...Lauren Tjaden - 2013/02/07 23:56:42 UTC
It is a great tragedy to lose someone so young and vital.
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=32824
Weaklink testing
...quite extensive experience.Mark Dowsett - 2013/07/04 21:41:52 UTC
I left Quest with some of the towmeup.com material when I was there in April and they were going to do testing as well. I'm not sure what they are now using.
Great Paul.I have witnessed countless others have weak link breaks with no serious problems.
- I've witnessed countless people:
-- whipstalling their gliders to dead stops in light switchy conditions
-- skipping preflight sidewire load tests and hook-in checks
-- launching with brake lever release actuators velcroed to their downtubes
with no serious problems.
- Have you:
-- witnessed countable others having weak link breaks with serious problems?
-- ever heard or read about anyone having a weak link break with a serious problem?
- Would you not consider Lauren's little romp...
...over the soybean field a very serious problem?Lauren Tjaden - 2003/12/14
But, my glider stalled quite dramatically almost instantly (hard not to stall when you have a break), and dove towards the ground (a bit disconcerting from so low).
- Couldn't Zack have had a fairly serious problem just getting dumped by a weak link break and having to land in the thermal (or invisible dust devil) that popped the planes up? Sounds like the Pilot In Command...
...didn't want any part of it.Mark Frutiger - 2013/02/08 19:12:21 UTC
The thermal was still active in the area that I had just launched from so I did a go round and landed on a runway 90 degrees cross to the direction we were towing in.
- Can you conceive of an unlikely hypothetical situation in which a weak link break could result in a very serious problem?
- I know you didn't actually see it happen but you're reporting on Zack Marzec having a fairly serious problem after his weak link broke. Are you gonna discount the possibility that his serious problem might have had something to do with the weak link break because you've witnessed countless others have weak link breaks with no serious problems?
- WITH NO SERIOUS PROBLEMS?!?!?! Weak links function ONLY to PREVENT serious problems.
-- Saying that you've witnessed countless others have weak link breaks with no serious problems is like saying you've seen people doing strong launch runs and clearing their turns with no serious problems.
-- And Jim Keen-Intellect Rooney ASSURES us that it's physically impossible to have so much as a MINOR problem with a weak link break - just an inconvenience. You really should get together with him so he can make you understand that you're not actually seeing any minor problems resulting from standard 130 pound test weak link pops.
- So aren't you gonna tell us about some of the countless lives you seen saved when these countless weak link breaks you've witnessed have prevented low level lockouts with no serious problems? You must have countless really amazing stories. Maybe you put a collection of them up on Quest's website.
- Ever consider going to something heavier than the standard 130 pound test weak link to get the number of weak link breaks you've witnessed down to countable levels? Nah...
Dr. Trisa Tilletti 1 - 2012/06
We know that some aerotow hang gliding operations and pilots experience a relatively high incidence of weak link breaks. Why do you think that happens?
That probably wouldn't work very well.Dr. Trisa Tilletti 2 - 2012/06
There are many reasons, but for most pilots it is not because the standard 130 lb. green spot Dacron line used to make weak links for hang gliders is too weak.
Well, yeah, but you're training them how to handle that situation...We train aero tow pilots how to handle this situation and I am certain that Zach had also encountered this situation many times before and knew how to react properly.
...at altitude in smooth air. And where Zack and Lauren and a lot of other folk seem to be having issues is shortly after takeoff in turbulent air. Have you thought any about changing your training protocol to even better prepare your aerotow pilots?The United States Hang Gliding and Paragliding Association, Inc. - 2012/06/20
Standard Operating Procedure
12. Rating System
02. Pilot Proficiency System
12. Hang Gliding Aerotow
-A. Aerotow
05. The candidate must also demonstrate the ability to properly react to a weak link/tow rope break simulation with a tandem rated pilot, initiated by the tandem pilot at altitude, but at a lower than normal release altitude. Such demonstrations should be made in smooth air.
Right. Probably a dust devil that morphed out of the smooth thermal Mark had flown through several seconds before and then morphed back into a thermal when he was turning back around to set up his landing.Apparently, Zach simply hit strong low level turbulence, probably a dust devil that could not be seen due to the lack of dust in Florida, the nose went too high and he tumbled at a very low altitude.
That's a real good thing, Paul. 'Cause thermals in Florida are common as shit - which is why Quest and Wallaby are located where they are and why people from all over the world flock to Quest and Wallaby. And we'd hate to think that a highly experienced standard 130 pound test weak link protected pro toad could get snuffed just by flying into a strong thermal at a hundred feet or so.Strong dust devils in Florida definitely do exist even though they are rare.
WHOA! DUDE! Definitely a good thing that they're rare.My wife had a near miss when she encountered a severe dusty a couple years ago and I almost lost a brand new $18,000 ATOS VX when it was torn from its tie down and thrown upside down.
Yeah, you're probably right. No need for the FAA to look into this and start wasting our time with a lot of stupid questions.I wish I could shed more light on this accident but I am afraid this is all we know and probably will know.
But if you really DO wanna shed some more light on this accident...
- Go up in smooth evening air with a pro toad bridle and a standard 130 pound test weak link.
- Pull the bar in at a hundred feet then shove it out hard to simulate Zack's climb.
- Wait for the standard 130 pound test weak link to pop. (Shouldn't take any more than a second or two.)
If the glider doesn't tailslide, whipstall, and tumble that'll be pretty good evidence to support your invisible dust devil hypothesis. (Have a couple of cameras running so we can have a productive discussion about the issue. And wear a good helmet - just in case.)
- Tad Eareckson
- Posts: 9161
- Joined: 2010/11/25 03:48:55 UTC
Re: Weak links
Hey Paul,
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
- Marzec tow configuration...
...including standard 130 pound test weak link.
- No dust devil, invisible or otherwise.
- Just got lifted and rolled by a couple of not terribly remarkable thermal surges.
- Took a hand off in an attempt to...
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3391
More on Zapata and weak link
- His Pilot In Command fixes what was going on back there by giving him the rope.
- With the bar stuffed he continues to pitch up until he's out of airspeed.
- Goes down like a fuckin' brick.
- Probably had too much VG on.
http://westcoastbrit.blogspot.com/2013/05/a-couple-of-weeks-ago-i-had-experience.html
Lock out on tow
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=32318
Lock Out
He doesn't tumble but if he'd been a little lower when the shit hit the fan he'd have been killed instantly - none of this "conscious immediately after the accident but died in route to the hospital" bullshit.
So where the hell were you, Lauren, Mark Frutiger, Mitch Shipley, Russell Brown, Jim Keen-Intellect Rooney, Bobby Fucking-Genius Bailey, Dr. Trisa Tilletti on THAT discussion?
---
Correction - 2017/05/02 01:40:00 UTC
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=30971
Zach Marzec
About three months later another fuckin' tandem instructor...Paul Tjaden - 2013/02/07 23:47:58 UTC
Beyond these facts anything else would be pure speculation. I have personally had numerous weak link breaks on tow, both low and high, after hitting turbulence and have never felt in danger of a tumble. I have witnessed countless others have weak link breaks with no serious problems. We train aero tow pilots how to handle this situation and I am certain that Zach had also encountered this situation many times before and knew how to react properly. Apparently, Zach simply hit strong low level turbulence, probably a dust devil that could not be seen due to the lack of dust in Florida, the nose went too high and he tumbled at a very low altitude.
I wish I could shed more light on this accident but I am afraid this is all we know and probably will know. Zach was a great guy with an incredible outlook and zest for life. He will be sorely missed.
- Marzec tow configuration...
...including standard 130 pound test weak link.
- No dust devil, invisible or otherwise.
- Just got lifted and rolled by a couple of not terribly remarkable thermal surges.
- Took a hand off in an attempt to...
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3391
More on Zapata and weak link
...get to one of his Industry Standard bent pin releases - well before his standard 130 pound test weak link was feeling much more pain than normal.Paul Tjaden - 2008/07/22 04:32:22 UTC
I have never had a lockout situation happen so quickly and dramatically and had no chance to release as I have always thought I could do.
- His Pilot In Command fixes what was going on back there by giving him the rope.
- With the bar stuffed he continues to pitch up until he's out of airspeed.
- Goes down like a fuckin' brick.
- Probably had too much VG on.
http://westcoastbrit.blogspot.com/2013/05/a-couple-of-weeks-ago-i-had-experience.html
Lock out on tow
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=32318
Lock Out
He doesn't tumble but if he'd been a little lower when the shit hit the fan he'd have been killed instantly - none of this "conscious immediately after the accident but died in route to the hospital" bullshit.
So where the hell were you, Lauren, Mark Frutiger, Mitch Shipley, Russell Brown, Jim Keen-Intellect Rooney, Bobby Fucking-Genius Bailey, Dr. Trisa Tilletti on THAT discussion?
---
Correction - 2017/05/02 01:40:00 UTC
Yeah, that one actually WAS a dust devil - strangely identified as such at the time.- No dust devil, invisible or otherwise...
- Tad Eareckson
- Posts: 9161
- Joined: 2010/11/25 03:48:55 UTC
Re: Weak links
http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=28290
Report about fatal accident at Quest Air Hang Gliding
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3600
Weak link question
- select and use his own equipment within the constraints of FAA regulations
- not be forced to use equipment falling below the minimum standards of FAA regulations
- remain with the powered aircraft until it's in a situation that allows him to survive the separation
It's a bitter pill I'm sure, but there you have it.
And what makes the pill even more bitter to swallow is that when the Pilot In Command:
- outfits the glider with equipment locks up, wraps, snags, disintegrates
- outclimbs the glider and lures it into nosing up to stay in position
- tows an unqualified student into a fatal lockout
- fixes whatever's going on back there by dumping the glider into an unrecoverable stall
He can instantly delegate Pilot In Command status to the glider. That way it's really hard for the tug not to accrue an absolutely outstanding safety record - and, of course, for the glider to not come out looking like an incompetent muppet at best or in one piece at worst.
Even though he's on a dangerously roll unstable aircraft and has some stupid motherfucker 250 feet away controlling his thrust, climb rate, direction whose situation will ALWAYS IMPROVE by dumping the glider into a stall, whatever bad happens to the glider will be ITS OWN FAULT and, if the tow continues to altitude successfully, the Pilot In Command is, obviously, the only individual who can claim credit.
Report about fatal accident at Quest Air Hang Gliding
Gee, didn't think we'd have to delve into "Pilot In Command"... I figured that one was pretty well understood in the flying community.Dennis Cavagnaro - 2013/02/09 15:55:00 UTC
I am very sad over the loss of a fellow pilot Zack and for the sad burden on the entire Quest community. We are pilots and in the end all judgement is the responsibility of the pilot in command.
Anyone that has some towing experience should know that there are circumstances and challenges that are unpredictable. that is way we as pilots need to be focused and ready. with a sailplane the tug pilot in an emergency can give you the rope at any time. We are trained to respond to this at all stages of the tow. First 50 foot 100 foot 200 foot etc.
the lesson I take from this tragic event is to have a action ready at every stage of the tow and anticipate as much as I can.
Lauren Paul and Mark the tug pilot my thoughts are with you doing this difficult time.
Peace,
Dennis
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3600
Weak link question
It's quite simple. The tug is a certified aircraft... The glider is an unpowered ultralight vehicle. The tug pilot is the Pilot In Command. The muppet on the glider is a passenger. He has the same rights and responsibilities as a skydiver - EXCEPT, of course, the rights to:Jim Rooney - 2008/11/24 05:18:15 UTC
Well, I'm assuming there was some guff about the tug pilot's right of refusal?
Gee, didn't think we'd have to delve into "pilot in command"... I figured that one's pretty well understood in a flying community.
It's quite simple.
The tug is a certified aircraft... the glider is an unpowered ultralight vehicle. The tug pilot is the pilot in command. You are a passenger. You have the same rights and responsibilities as a skydiver.
It's a bitter pill I'm sure, but there you have it.
- select and use his own equipment within the constraints of FAA regulations
- not be forced to use equipment falling below the minimum standards of FAA regulations
- remain with the powered aircraft until it's in a situation that allows him to survive the separation
It's a bitter pill I'm sure, but there you have it.
And what makes the pill even more bitter to swallow is that when the Pilot In Command:
- outfits the glider with equipment locks up, wraps, snags, disintegrates
- outclimbs the glider and lures it into nosing up to stay in position
- tows an unqualified student into a fatal lockout
- fixes whatever's going on back there by dumping the glider into an unrecoverable stall
He can instantly delegate Pilot In Command status to the glider. That way it's really hard for the tug not to accrue an absolutely outstanding safety record - and, of course, for the glider to not come out looking like an incompetent muppet at best or in one piece at worst.
Even though he's on a dangerously roll unstable aircraft and has some stupid motherfucker 250 feet away controlling his thrust, climb rate, direction whose situation will ALWAYS IMPROVE by dumping the glider into a stall, whatever bad happens to the glider will be ITS OWN FAULT and, if the tow continues to altitude successfully, the Pilot In Command is, obviously, the only individual who can claim credit.