http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=33814
USHPA CGL insurance update
Dan Moser - 2016/01/12 00:21:52 UTC
Sandy, Utah
Here's a question that I hope can be answered:
Where can we find the raw data on the recent problematic insurance claims that have been made?
Same place you can find all the raw data on u$hPa hang gliding crash reports.
In particular, what are the details of the claims that directly resulted in the horrible insurance situation in which we now find ourselves?
I'm looking for the specific who, where, when and why of these problematic claims.
Perhaps I missed it, but the detailed facts about the problematic claims have not been discussed .. though perhaps they were, and were merely drowned out amid the many load pronouncements that the USHPA rank & file should just cough up more insurance money and quit bitchin' about it ..
More money for self-insurance may in fact be the best way out of this mess, but where are the facts that explain how we have ended up here?
Without knowing the factual root causes, how can we hope to determine the best solution going forward?
Just keep trusting Tim Herr and Mark G. Forbes. We've got a proven system that works and if something ain't broke...
Please don't reply with caustic opinions & counter-opinions.
I'm just asking for the detailed factual evidence on the problematic insurance claims that have directly resulted in the current situation ... slim chance, right?
A happy & high-flyin' 2016 to all!
Mark G. Forbes - 2016/01/12 00:40:14 UTC
The information you're asking for is confidential and may not be released. I'm sorry, but that's the advice of our attorney.
Our recreational hang glider pilot attorney who's never had anything but the interests of the recreational hang glider pilot in his heart and has skillfully guided the sport to the supreme evolutionary level at which we see it today.
He has explained why that is the case and I'm satisfied that the reasons justify keeping the details confidential.
Well if you're satisfied with something, Mark, it's a fuckin' no brainer that ALL OF US should be absolutely ECSTATIC with it - at a bare minimum.
What information we can release is aggregated, and is available on a link from the FAQ.
And, of course, is reflected in the SOPs, which are constantly being upgraded and refined as we become more and more knowledgeable about the risks to which our sport exposes third parties - really freak stuff that would have never occurred to anyone just trying to think things through or applying blindingly obvious common sense.
What I can tell you is that public disclosure of the intimate details of claims would not provide any insight into how to prevent future high-cost claims, and would instead give plaintiff's attorneys additional insight into how to structure future claims against us.
I'd like to think that I do a pretty good job of doing that over here. My credentials:
Tad Eareckson - 32674 - 2009/08/31 - H4 - 1991/12/17 - Santos Mendoza - AT FL PA VA AWCL CL FSL RLF TUR XC
Tim's:
Timothy Herr - 48274
If you need a capsule summary, here's what to know:
1) Don't damage spectators. Hit ANYTHING ELSE first. Don't allow spectators in close to gliders. Don't let them sit on the hill down-slope from launch and take pictures. Keep them back from gliders far enough that if a launch goes bad and a pilot spins into the hill, they don't hit a spectator. Keep them out of the LZ when gliders are landing.
2) Park vehicles away from launch and landing areas. Don't plan your landing for an easy walk to the car; land out in the middle of the field. If you're holding a spot landing contest, put the target well out in the middle of the landing area, not near spectators.
3) Leave plenty of clearance from power lines. Don't launch at sites with strong wind where there's a power line behind launch. Set up approaches well clear of power lines. Pre-walk LZs at a new site to check for overhead wires.
4) You're personally responsible for your own safety. Don't sue other pilots, instructors, landowners or USHPA if you get hurt. No matter what happens, no matter who did what, YOU are the pilot in command and ultimately responsible for your own safety.
5) Follow the USHPA recommendations for operating limits. Those rules exist for a reason, to improve your safety. They were developed from past experience and accidents.
6) Hang check! Make sure you're connected to the glider. Leg straps, carabiners locked, zippers closed. Don't unhook once you're in and checked, unless you take the harness off and restart the process. No walking around on launch in your harness....it's part of the glider.
1) Don't damage spectators. Hit ANYTHING ELSE first.
Got that, everybody? And if somebody runs up to help you hold your glider down and keep it from being blown into powerlines or slamming into other gliders, vehicles, kids, dogs and gets permanently demolished for his efforts then call him a clueless spectator and piss all over him for as many years as the incident remains in memory.
Don't allow spectators in close to gliders.
Yeah. Whenever a member of the public at a public launch site expresses interest in what you're doing and wants to learn as much as possible about it tell him to fuck off and clear out. We need to keep the future of the sport foremost in our considerations.
Don't let them sit on the hill down-slope from launch and take pictures.
And if someone does anyway and something interesting happens make sure to grab his camera and swallow the card.
Keep them back from gliders far enough that if a launch goes bad and a pilot spins into the hill, they don't hit a spectator. Keep them out of the LZ when gliders are landing.
Yeah. We're skimming in at up to 25 mph! Shit really happens fast at speeds like that.
2) Park vehicles away from launch and landing areas. Don't plan your landing for an easy walk to the car; land out in the middle of the field.
Aim for the old Frisbee dead centered and avoid the downwind third like the fuckin' plague.
If you're holding a spot landing contest...
http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=21088
What you wish you'd known then?
Doug Doerfler - 2011/03/02 05:24:44 UTC
Nothing creates carnage like declaring a spot landing contest.
...you should have your fuckin' rating permanently revoked.
...put the target well out in the middle of the landing area, not near spectators.
Yeah Mark. Spectators are being hit by gliders in the courses of spot landing contests.
3) Leave plenty of clearance from power lines.
Come in fifty feet over them - and never worry about the trees at the upwind end of the runway.
Don't launch at sites with strong wind where there's a power line behind launch.
Fuck no! You might hit the powerline behind launch. Or the cars in the parking lot! Or the gliders in the setup area! Or the kids and dogs playing in the staging area! Just play it safe and never launch in strong winds!
Set up approaches well clear of power lines. Pre-walk LZs at a new site to check for overhead wires.
'Specially when you're flying XC.
4) You're personally responsible for your own safety. Don't sue other pilots, instructors, landowners or USHPA if you get hurt. No matter what happens, no matter who did what, YOU are the pilot in command and ultimately responsible for your own safety.
http://www.chgpa.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3600
Weak link question
Jim Rooney - 2008/11/24 05:18:15 UTC
Well, I'm assuming there was some guff about the tug pilot's right of refusal?
Gee, didn't think we'd have to delve into "pilot in command"... I figured that one's pretty well understood in a flying community.
It's quite simple.
The tug is a certified aircraft... the glider is an unpowered ultralight vehicle. The tug pilot is the pilot in command. You are a passenger. You have the same rights and responsibilities as a skydiver.
It's a bitter pill I'm sure, but there you have it.
BTW, if you think I'm just spouting theory here, I've personally refused to tow a flight park owner over this very issue. I didn't want to clash, but I wasn't towing him. Yup, he wanted to tow with a doubled up weaklink. He eventually towed (behind me) with a single and sorry to disappoint any drama mongers, we're still friends. And lone gun crazy Rooney? Ten other tow pilots turned him down that day for the same reason.
http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=12443
AT regs
Mark G. Forbes - 2009/06/13 04:27:43 UTC
Action comes more swiftly when there's a clear threat to safety. I'm not seeing evidence (in the form of accidents or fatalities) that demonstrate that there's a major problem. There may be room for improvement, and that's certainly worth considering as we review and update our procedures, but I don't see the urgency of adopting these changes without careful consideration and the input of lots of other people involved in aerotowing. I'd want to hear what Steve Wendt, Jim Rooney, Malcolm Jones, Bobby Bailey, Steve Kroop, Dave Glover, John Kemmeries, Hungary Joe and others have to say as well. As your proposed language stands today, I would vote against it based on my concerns. That's not to say that you're wrong, but I haven't bought into your proposal yet myself, and I haven't heard other viewpoints sufficient to form an opinion that's favorable.
Suck my dick, Mark.
5) Follow the USHPA recommendations for operating limits.
Yeah...
Assisted Windy Cliff or Ramp Launch (AWCL)
Demonstrates ability to launch with wire assist in windy conditions from a precipitous cliff or ramp with strong lift at takeoff. Must show proper use of release signals and confident, aggressive launch.
We're taking that one off the books and making it a punishable offense to launch with wire assist in windy conditions from a precipitous cliff or ramp with strong lift at takeoff.
Those rules exist for a reason, to improve your safety.
Just like the Rooney Link.
They were developed from past experience and accidents.
- Just like the Rooney Link.
- Sure they were, Mark.
6) Hang check!
FUCK YEAH!
Make sure you're connected to the glider.
DAMN STRAIGHT!!! Before you get up on that ramp you wanna be one hundred percent absolutely POSITIVE you're connected to it!
Leg straps...
And no fuckin' way you can miss leg straps if you do a hang check! Checking leg loops is one of Joe Greblo's Four or Five Cs!
...carabiners locked...
Lock those carabiners! Three pilots last year fell out of their gliders and landed on expensive SUVs because their carabiners weren't locked.
...zippers closed.
Make sure those zippers are closed. I can't emphasize too much how dangerous it is for pilots and spectators alike when people launch with open zippers.
Don't unhook once you're in and checked...
Fuck no. Don't EVER unhook to adjust a camera, secure a batten, retrieve a cell phone. If you do you're a total idiot. You're probably gonna die and your glider's probably gonna short out some powerlines.
...unless you take the harness off and restart the process. No walking around on launch in your harness....it's part of the glider.
http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=13359
Today was a bad day!
Mike Bomstad - 2009/08/26 04:21:15 UTC
The harness is part of the aircraft... end of story.
(Just because it's easy to remove, does not mean it should be. Dont choose the path of least resistance)
Attach it to the wing, completing the aircraft.... then preflight the completed aircraft.
Buckle yourself into the cockpit and then your ready.
11-A12819
http://c1.staticflickr.com/9/8339/28924980016_2ba1d20ef7_o.png
http://c1.staticflickr.com/9/8253/28924975726_0d24a615c2_o.png
13-A14319
End of story!
Fuck you and Tim and the horses you rode in on.
And fuck you, Eric Hinrichs...
http://http://www.hanggliding.org/viewtopic.php?t=21868
Don't Forget your Hang Check!
Eric Hinrichs - 2011/05/13 21:31:06 UTC
I went to Chelan for the Nationals in '95 as a free flyer. They were requiring everyone to use the Australian method, and you were also not allowed to carry a glider without being hooked in.
This was different for me, I hook in and do a full hang check just behind launch right before I go. I was also taught to do a hooked in check right before starting my run, lifting or letting the wind lift the glider to feel the tug of the leg loops.
So I used their method and I'm hooked in, carrying my glider to launch and someone yells "Dust devil!" Everyone around runs for their gliders (most of which are tied down) and I'm left standing alone in the middle of the butte with a huge monster wandering around. I heard later that it was well over three hundred feet tall, and some saw lightning at the top. After that it was clear that no one is going to decide for me or deride me for my own safety methods, someone else's could have easily got me killed.
...for allowing this asshole to spew this Aussie Methodist shit and get away with it.