Bob Buxton Truck Tow Accident Video
Yes. SO much.Dave Hopkins - 2013/02/10 17:17:41 UTC
Thanks for posting the video there is much to be learned
- Always route the bridle UNDER the basetube. (I just can't stress that enough.)
- NEVER use a release that you'll be able to blow in an emergency. That shit doesn't work. If it did, we'd be using it everywhere. Stick with Industry Standard equipment you KNOW won't work because that's what we use everywhere so it has a really long track record.
None of which, of course, include the dope on the rope releasing himself.There was time to do many things.
No fuckin' way!First, the winch operator should have seen the line over the base tube before launch . Was he a pilot?
- ANYONE who's a PILOT (except, of course, the guy under the glider) would have spotted that problem in an instant.
- Noting that the bridle was routed over - instead of under - the bar would simply be far beyond the capabilities of anyone who ISN'T a PILOT.
No, by the time they finished the briefing on how to stare at the pressure gauge no matter what the soaring window was just about over.Was he briefed on how everything should look before and during the launch. Was he briefed when to release pressure.
How 'bout a release the guy on the glider can actually use when he needs to as a primary? Just kidding.At the first sign of trouble he should have free wheeled the reel. He should also have a kill switch for the truck. An other question , did the winch have an instant pressure release handle. I mean instant, not a knob to turn to adjust pressure. If not I would not fly with it. I have seen many that don't. Of course the hook knife as a backup.
The pilot had time to change his vario batteries.The pilot had time to release.
Because he only had two hands and he was flying a system designed for someone with three.Why didn't he release?
Whereas they're EXCELLENT protection from a lockout on aero - as Roy Messing demonstrated so clearly at Whitewater on 2009/08/31. And they're also totally awesome at protecting us from excessive angles of attack - as Zack Marzec demonstrated at Quest on 2013/02/02.This a good example of why weak links don't protect us from a lockout using a payout winch.
Since we've already eliminated the pilot's release as a viable option.The winch operator is our only protection they need to be well briefed on when to release pressure.
Of course it would. It's physically impossible for an aerotowed glider to hit the ground in a low level lockout with the weak link still intact. And it's also physically impossible for a standard aerotow weak link to hold long enough in a lockout to leave the glider incapable of recovering in time for a textbook standup landing.The weak link would have failed had this been aerotow.
Focal point of a safe towing system dude. Guaranteed to keep you from getting into too much trouble.I'm not saying aerotow is safer just that the weak link is more effective if a lockout gets started.
Hey! Did anybody think of locking up the winch in a low level lockout so the payout weak link will be just as effective as an aero weak link?
Yeah, I was gonna say something about that. Whenever you've misrouted your bridle, have an inaccessible release, and are bobbing around behind a truck with a couple of bozos totally asleep at the switch you should stop flying the glider and use that opportunity to climb up into the control frame. Hard to imagine how he missed out on that training.As always when the ground is coming up fast, get off the base bar , Grab the uprights and pull your butt into the frame and make the glider take the impact.
Have you given any thought to seeing how continuing to fly the glider instead of climbing into the control bar might have worked? Is that what you do in your car whenever you see a telephone pole you might hit? Dive into the back seat so when you do hit it your situation will be a lot more survivable?This is pet peeve of mine. Telling pilots to let go of the glider in a sever crash is wrong! Climbing into the bar has saved my life at least 5 times over the yrs.
Ya know sumpin', Dave... If you've had to let go of the downtubes hundreds of times to save them and are an expert at reacting in real high energy impacts I think you might wanna reconsider some of your fundamental approaches to this aviation thing.Sure I have let go of the bars a hundred times to save the downtubes but in a real high energy impact I know what to do.
This is reminding me a lot of people who a really great at reacting to unhooked launches and standard aerotow weak link successes.
I'm gonna be conducting a jihad against him.miguel - 2012/01/20 01:40:10 UTC
Research "Dave Hopkins" if you are not conducting jihad against him. He piled a Mitchell wing into the rocks on the side of the hill at McClure at 60-70mph. Walked away with trivial minor injuries.
And you STILL crashed? I guess an instant elimination of towline tension only ensures a safe timely regain of control if it's effected by a weak link failure.One of those crashes was a lockout on a payout winch. The operator released pressure.
So...That is what saved me. I was knocked out but was uninjured because my head was up and I hit the ground with my lower body. it's made for a beating.
http://ozreport.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=25015
Zippy pounds in
Just how many times have you been knocked out after climbing into the control frame? Do you think there might be some kind of correlation between the number of times you've been knocked out and your propensity to keep climbing into the control frame at the expense of continuing to fly the glider?Davis Straub - 2011/09/02 18:37:09 UTC
Concussions are in fact very serious and have life long effects. The last time I was knocked out what in 9th grade football. I have felt the effects of that ever since. It changes your wiring.
And sumpin' else, Dave... How do you manage to get into a dangerous low level lockout on a payout winch? Are you friends with John Woiwode or Peter Birren?
Yeah Dave...heal fast Bob., spring is coming.
He's gonna have a speedy recovery 'cause everyone's wishing him one. Two or three more well-wishes and denials of reality and he should be in tiptop shape by mid April.Scott Buxton - 2013/02/10 10:17:16 UTC
Bob is still recovering at Health South Rehab Facility in Glendale. Bob suffered a severe head injury (bleeding on the brain). He still has a long road ahead of him in recovering.
No... Just stunningly clueless.I hope I'm not being too insensitive here